Recently, I was given a deck of conversation cards that had different topics related to church life. It’s actually posed as a game, and outside of the discussion cards there are response cards dished out to the players. One if you agree, one if you disagree. Once the players respond, everyone gets a change to defend their response and see if they can “convert” another player into changing their perspective. Points are gained by majority rules, but you can gain bonus points through this conversion twist.
First, let me point out that this gives me a LOT of varying thoughts. I’m probably going to use this game in speaking illustrations in the future. But, the point of my starting this post was that I actually think some of the discussion points in the game are pretty solid and worth discussing here.
Today’s topic…. Dating and the Church:
A person should leave their home church if they break up with someone that attends their same church.
I really wasn’t a regular attender of church until I was married, I also married really young. When it came to dating, I was really protective of my space. I didn’t date anyone in high school who actually attended my school. In college, we didn’t share any mutual classes. When I started working, I never dated a coworker. I’ve never really had to deal with a break up in a shared space or community. This was 100% intentional on my part, because of this vary discussion question. What do you do when you have to see this person regularly, especially if the break up was messy?
If I was a single in church, I am guessing I would have probably applied the same principles and avoided dating someone that I attended church with, for this very reason… a messy break up creates an awkward atmosphere. So unless you attend a church with more than one service, or that is so large you can avoid each other… what do you do? What does this look like if you are serving on the same team (like both on the worship team)? I think a mutual decision that it’s not the right fit is easier, or if it was just a couple of dates and you both decided the chemistry wasn’t their. However, if this was a long term relationship or the circumstances of the breakup were not mutual… yikes.
But this your church family, it’s not exactly easy to just pick up and go somewhere else.
While I think if I were single, I wouldn’t date someone from my church in principle… I also think that if we broke up, I could manage being in the same building under most normal circumstances of breakup. If it was super traumatic, I could see myself taking a few weeks off but eventually coming back. I also think that if the circumstances were extreme, I could see myself speaking with church leadership about it (if the person was in need of guidance, correction).
As a church leader, I also think I would be very understanding of someone choosing to leave the church because it was too difficult and no way to avoid one another. But, I would caution that person because eventually you’ll run out of churches to switch to. I think I would try to help the person stay if at all possible.
I’m definitely curious about the dating experiences of people dating in their local churches, share if you feel comfortable. Also curious about how church leaders have dealt with the relationships that come and go in their churches.